Why Cybersecurity Keeps Failing and How We Can Rebuild It
This index is one number from a larger argument: that cybersecurity’s failure is
structural, not technical. The foundations were wrong from the start, but we can rebuild.
Reported cybercrime losses have outgrown the stock market by more than six to one.
The Hacker in a Hoodie Index is the record behind that claim: what individual cyber incidents actually cost, each figure read from the document that reported it.
The index
What $100 became · 2014 → 2024
One hundred dollars, tracked two ways since 2014. The gap is the story.
Over 2014 to 2024, $100 tracking cybercrime losses reported to the FBI grew to $2,074, while $100 in the S&P 500 with dividends reinvested grew to $343: a difference of 6.05 times.
Hackers in hoodies2014
$100
S&P 500, dividends reinvested
$100
6.05×
Cybercrime loss outgrew the market over the decade: $2,074 against $343, both in nominal dollars, measured from year-end 2014 to year-end 2024.
Hacker in a Hoodie Index: reported losses to the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, $800,492,073 in 2014 against $16,600,000,000 in 2024. Compound annual growth rate 35.42 percent.
35.4%/yr10-year window · 2014–2024
34.2%/yrfull record · 2001–2025
The IC3 growth rate barely moves across windows. The index is not built on a chosen base year, and the 6.05x multiple compares like with like: both figures are measured from year-end 2014 to year-end 2024, both in nominal dollars.
THE INDEX · LIVE · 2014 = 100
The gap is still widening
6.05x was the first reading, taken through 2024. The index carries it forward. As of 2025 it stands at 6.48x, and it moves as the ecosystem does.
BOOK · 2014-2024
6.05x
the first reading
LIVE · 2014-2025
6.48x
where it stands now
Cybercrime loss (FBI IC3) and S&P 500 total return, each indexed to 100 at year-end 2014, both nominal. In 2025 reported loss rose 25.8% while the market rose 17.44%, so the gap widened from 6.05x to 6.48x. The book's 6.05x is the 2014-2024 reading and does not change; the index recomputes as each year posts.
Follow the record
New figures as they clear verification, and the occasional note from behind the index. No more email than the work warrants.
Index updates, no more. No list sharing.
The Losses, Side By Side
What we’ve lost, by the numbers
Two documented measures of annual cybercrime loss, one log scale. The FBI IC3 series is a continuous
annual reading from 2014 to 2025, and by the FBI’s own account a significant underestimation.
These numbers are reported figures only. Chainalysis provides a yearly view of ransom payments.
IC3 reported losses / US complaints / Verified
Chainalysis ransom payments / on-chain / revised
About that trillion-dollar number: the $10.5 trillion often quoted for global cybercrime is a
forward projection from Cybersecurity Ventures, compounded from a 2015 base whose methodology is not
disclosed. Because it is assumed rather than measured, it is excluded from the chart and the ledger,
and noted only here. The trillion-dollar figure is constantly referred to in public messaging and
presentations, due to the propagation of those numbers in AI learning data. Cybersecurity Ventures
has never provided data that supports this forecast.
About 2010: the IC3 line skips 2010. The FBI’s own retrospective plots that year near $1.0B
while its contemporaneous 2010 report recorded $485M. The two cannot both be right, so we leave the
point out rather than choose.
The consequences that barely moved
Cost per breach barely moved.
Across more than a decade, while aggregate reported losses compounded at double digits, the modeled
cost of a single breach grew about 3% a year, from $3.5M in 2014 to a record
$4.99M in 2026.
If the per-event price is growing in the low single digits while the total keeps compounding at
double digits, the growth is in volume and attack surface, not in severity. That is a finding the
headline trillion-dollar number hides.
IBM’s figure is the cost of one breach, shown here for shape, not added to the totals above.
Someone was working inside Lamb Weston's systems from January 9 to January 15, 2026, six days of unauthorized activity that stopped only when it was discovered. The Oregon filing puts the affected at 7,175 people and is silent on both the entry point and the data taken. Letters began going out September 29, more than eight months after the activity was caught. A notice that names neither the door nor the contents leaves 7,175 people wondering why a global frozen french fry manufacturer spilled the spuds on this one.
Every loss here is Verified — the company’s own SEC filing states the figure, and the company name links to it. One incident, one figure, ranked by size, never rolled into a single total. Sort by any column.
The 10 largest of 30 Verified losses · each stated by the company’s own filing · one figure each, never added together · click a heading to sort
How each figure is gradedVVerifiedthe linked primary document states itAAttesteda published report credits a named sourceIInferredno direct confirmation; a lead, not a figureThe full standard →
On the Government Record · live
43SEC 8-K cyber-incident disclosures logged · 2026 year to date
All Verified · SEC 8-K cyber-incident filings, Item 1.05, Item 8.01, and Item 7.01
This counts the cyber incidents companies disclosed to the SEC on Form 8-K this year — the material-incident filings under Item 1.05, the cyber events reported under Item 8.01, and cyber disclosures made under Item 7.01 (Regulation FD). It is a count of disclosures, not a measure of total losses: most incidents never reach a public filing, and many are reported before any dollar figure exists. The ledger below also carries state-regulator breach and enforcement records, shown for context but not included in this count. It counts disclosed filings and never sums their figures.
Telecare Health's network was breached in an incident discovered January 25, 2026; the filing names neither the entry point nor the number of patients affected. What left was the whole clinical person: names, Social Security numbers, driver's licenses, diagnoses, lab results, treatments, insurance details. The ransomware group Qilin claims the theft and threatens to leak it. It took until September 4 merely to inventory what one network had been holding all along.
Healthcare and Life Sciences
California AG breach notification
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft confirmed+ data extortion·Actor Qilin
Baker Tilly's clients and their dependents had their personal data obtained from a platform run by a third-party provider, the firm has not named. The Texas filing puts the state's share at 10,456 people, with Social Security numbers, names, and addresses exposed; how the actor got in, and when, goes unsaid. An accounting firm's real security boundary was a vendor's platform, and the notice won't even name it.
Professional and Business Services
California AG breach notification
Initial attack type third-party or supply chain inferred·Impact data theft confirmed
Kalahari Management Co. LLC, operator of Kalahari Resorts & Conventions, caught suspicious activity on its network around October 16, 2026, after intruders had already reached its files. Those files possibly held names, Social Security numbers, dates of birth, and addresses for thousands of people. The notice is silent on the entry point and on how long anyone was inside. Getting onto the network meant getting to the files, which is what a network built with an unlocked gate allows.
Retail and Consumer
California AG breach notification
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft inferred
Cornick, Garber & Sandler, LLP had an intruder on its network from February 14 to March 26, 2025, with access to names, birthdates, Social Security numbers, license and taxpayer IDs, health insurance details, and account numbers. Neither the entry point nor the count of people affected appears in any filing. The notice came a year after the window closed, and the November 2026 supplement added nothing to the update. An update, with no updates.
Professional and Business Services
California AG breach notification
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft inferred
An unauthorized party had access to Hollister Family Dental & Implant Center's data from February 12 to May 8, 2026, nearly three months. The California filing names no entry point and no data types, and the record cannot even settle whether the intrusion hit the practice's own network or a third party's environment. Outside reports put the count near 3,809 people. Twelve weeks of open access says nobody was watching the door.
Healthcare and Life Sciences
California AG breach notification
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft inferred
Some losses surface outside any SEC filing: in a company’s own statement, a regulator or court record, or a news report crediting an identifiable source. Each is admitted on that attribution and graded by its strength. A figure credibly attributed to the company, a regulator, or a court is Attested; an estimate or reconstruction is Inferred. Each is logged with its source and grade; an incident’s verified losses total into its cost, and are never combined across incidents.
A server behind Fullerton Health's support of Singapore's Migrant Worker Primary Care Plan was accessed without authorization, and the company learned of it on October 31; the entry point, the attacker, the window, and the number of workers affected all go unsaid. The "standalone" system was isolated from everything except the data worth stealing: names, Foreign Identification Numbers, birthdates, phone numbers, emails, and home addresses. No medical or financial data, the notice stresses, as though a person's whole identity were a minor matter.
Healthcare and Life Sciences
Fullerton Health hit by cyber attack, personal data of migrant workers exposed
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft confirmed
A threat actor took data from a local system on the OCF/LF Logistics platform, which Maersk acquired with LF Logistics from Li & Fung Group in 2022; the entry point and the date go unstated. WhiteArmor claims about 100GB, including nearly 30,000 driver records, plaintext passwords, and 33 SUPER_ADMIN accounts. Maersk calls the incident isolated and the data not sensitive. An acquisition buys the inherited architecture, and if the group is right, that includes passwords nobody ever got around to hashing.
Transportation and Logistics
Maersk confirms data breach as WhiteArmor ransomware demands $5 million
Coordinated attacks reached five SPH Media systems and exposed data equal to 9% of its database: mostly email addresses, plus some names, mailing addresses, and phone numbers. The company attributes all of it to one unnamed actor and has not said when the access began or ended. The Straits Times credits software bugs and system configuration, which makes the attacker the least interesting part of the story. One actor reaching five systems means the structural weakness was shared long before anyone arrived.
Media and Entertainment
SPH Media Says Cyberattacks Exposed Data Equal to 9% of Its Database
Initial attack type software vulnerability inferred·Impact data theft confirmed
Vanderbilt was fighting active ransomware on November 9, ordering the whole campus to shut down university devices and get off its WiFi. The university has named no entry point, no data, and no count. The BYOD gang claims over a million Social Security numbers, research data, student and employee records, and the domain controller itself. When the only safe instruction is to unplug every school laptop at once, the network was built around one over-subscribed domain.
An unnamed actor reached personal data submitted through online forms on 14 York University websites, nineteen years of submissions, with the access discovered on October 25. The notice does not say how the actor got in or how many people are affected. Departmental forms gathered health details, criminal backgrounds, and government IDs and kept them since 2007, turning a web form into an archive nobody governed as one. Credit monitoring covers the ID numbers but doesn't cover the senstive information that can never be reissued.
Public Sector and Education
York University breach exposed personal information dating to 2007
Initial attack typenot disclosed·Impact data theft confirmed
FROM THE LEDGER · INCIDENT COUNT · n = 463 incidents
Which sectors the tracked incidents fall in: a count of incidents, not a total of dollars. Each bar is that sector’s share of the 463 on the record, ranked; a floor, not a census.
Share of incidents tracked on this ledger, not of all breaches. Healthcare leads partly because mandatory breach-disclosure rules in that sector put more of its incidents into the public record, not because it is necessarily attacked more often.
THE RULE
It would be tempting to add these numbers up and put one big total at the top of the page. We do not,
and we never will. Each line measures something different: different victims, different crimes,
different units, overlapping in some places and blind to each other in others. Add them together and
you get a number that means nothing, the kind of headline figure this index was built to refuse. So
the sources stay side by side, each labeled for what it counts, and the arithmetic stays honest.
THE FLOOR
The other temptation is to estimate what is missing and call the result the real number. We do not, and we never will. These are the losses someone measured. What no one measured has no number, only its absence. A figure that claims to cover the whole is not a larger version of this page. It is a projection, not a statistic.